Categories
The ESG Report

Legal Contracts for ESG with Sarah Dadush and David Snyder

Tom Fox welcomes  to this episode of the ESG Report. They are both law professors with backgrounds in human rights. In this conversation, they join Tom Fox to talk about the role of contracting in ESG.

Robust Supplier Codes of Conduct

Tom asks what steps are being taken to build more robust contract clauses. David explains that the process is still fairly in its initial state. Business lawyers have only recently adopted policies against forced labor and child labor. Lawyers are advising their clients to sign on to these policies, which is only one of the first few steps. Getting them implemented, however, is the true challenge. “The policies sit there in the corporate minutes, and unless they’re in the contracts, they’re not going to be implemented,” David says. These policies need to be in operation.  “To get them implemented, to get them operationalized, they need to be in the contracts.”

 

Human Rights, Model Clauses & ESG

“Part of the history of ESG is focusing on equipping consumers to make choices that are more and more aligned with their values,” Sarah tells Tom. This has expanded to include not only consumers but investors, thus bringing in more money and leverage to influence corporate behavior. The S in ESG comes into play with model clauses because it looks at human rights and employee rights. “Our focus within the model contract laws is on worker protection,” Sarah remarks. “We tend to think often of things like child labor, trafficked labor, forced labor in various shades. What we are including or addressing specifically in the model contract laws is worker conditions.”

 

Model Clauses & Regulatory Obligations 

Tom asks if model clauses can help companies meet their regulatory requirements. With model contract clauses in place, human rights due diligence are going to be more effective, David and Sarah agree. “They show the regulators that you are serious about doing something about this,” David remarks. However, model contracts need to be put into place. If they are signed but not acted upon, all you have is paper. “Once you’ve agreed to this human rights due diligence or a due diligence regime, and then we also have clauses about sharing information and generating documentation, then you are going to be able to document what you have done,” David adds. 

Sharing information will result in communication and documentation of what’s going on at the company. 

 

Resources

Sarah Dadush | LinkedIn 

David Snyder | LinkedIn

 

Categories
The ESG Compliance Podcast

Contracting for ESG with Sarah Dadush and David Snyder


Attorneys and professors in law David Snyder and Sarah Dadush join the podcast to discuss the role of contracting in ESG, how a conventional approach to writing contracts may not be the best choice, which issues are fixed, and how accountability should be on both the buyer and supplier.
▶️ Contracting for ESG with David Snyder and Sarah Dadush:
Key points discussed in the episode:
✔️ Supply chains are doing enough for ESG compliance. David Snyder and Sarah Dadush aim to combat this with more effective measures.
✔️ Policies remain unimplemented if they aren’t in the contract. Having a supplier code of conduct written with the assistance of a business lawyer isn’t enough to create change.
✔️ Working at an oil refinery helped David Snyder learn the true culprit – organized crime. He wanted human and environmental efforts to be treated the same way as product manufacturing.
✔️ ESG can impact both consumer and investor decisions. The California Supply Chains Transparency Act pushed for full disclosure directed at the customers.
✔️ Focusing only on forced labor leaves out other problems.
✔️ Traditional approaches to contracting ESG don’t work, Sarah Dadush says. Not only does it aggravate human rights risks but also increases the company’s chances of legal violations.
✔️ David Snyder emphasizes the importance of risk as part of supply chain management and compliance obligations. Lawyers should also play their part in handling clients properly instead of resorting to risk shifting.
✔️ Contracts don’t fix all supply chain issues. It all boils down to supply chain resilience. A weaker foundation puts companies in greater danger, especially in times of difficulty like the COVID-19 pandemic.
✔️ Buyers should be responsible when exiting contracts. Contracts have been misused at the height of the pandemic, and consumers are now urging businesses to be accountable for their shortcomings.
David Snyder was appointed professor of law at the American University Washington College of Law in the fall of 2007 and was appointed director of the Business Law Program in 2008. During 2021-2022, he also holds a Fernand Braudel Senior Fellowship at the European University Institute (Florence). He graduated summa cum laude from Tulane University Law School in 1991, and he has been a professor of law at Tulane, Indiana (Bloomington), and Cleveland-Marshall College of Law. He has been a regular visiting professor at the law school of the University of Paris II (Panthéon-Assas) since 2012, and has also been a visiting professor at the University of Paris 10 (Nanterre La Défense), Boston University, and the College of William and Mary. In addition, he has taught summer courses at the University of Mainz (Germany). After graduating from law school, Professor Snyder served as a law clerk to the Honorable John M. Duhé Jr. of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, and subsequently joined the D.C. firm of Hogan & Hartson (now Hogan Lovells). In 2014 Professor Snyder was awarded a MacCormick Fellowship during which he delivered the annual Wilson Memorial Lecture at the University of Edinburgh.
Sarah Dadush’s research lies at the intersection of business and human rights. Her scholarship explores various innovative legal mechanisms for improving the social and environmental performance of multinational corporations. She directs the Law School’s newly-established Business & Human Rights Law Program and co-leads an ABA Business Law Section Working Group that has developed a comprehensive toolkit for upgrading international supply contracts to better protect workers’ human rights.
—————————————————————————-
Do you have a podcast (or do you want to)? Join the only network dedicated to compliance, risk management, and business ethics, the Compliance Podcast Network. For more information, contact Tom Fox at tfox@tfoxlaw.com.