Categories
Reconstructing Immigration

Reconstructing Immigration: Episode 5 – We’ve Done This Before

Immigration is argued in America as a question of borders, crime, and culture. It is actually a question of labor supply, and the people who feel that most directly are the ones trying to staff a job site, a hospital floor, a kitchen, or a fabrication yard. This series makes the economic case, one argument per episode, in the language business owners already use: head count, cost base, compliance risk, and competitive position. It does not relitigate the politics. It reframes the problem as a workforce problem and ends with what an employer can actually do about it. The theme of the entire series is that America has spent forty years treating its largest economic asset as a liability, and the bill is now coming due in wages, prices, and growth.

In Episode 5, we look at two prior US government efforts at mass deportation in living memory. Both times, they damaged the economy, failed on their own terms, and left the underlying labor demand untouched. Additionally, we consider how these actions not only directly hurt the US national economy but also US national security.

The Conversation

1.  Why lead a business argument with a story from 1955?

2.  The two mass campaigns — what actually happened?

3.  Why does an approach with that record keep coming back?

4.  Put a price on doing it again.

5. “Enforcing the law isn’t optional. What’s your alternative — open borders?”

Soundbite

“We ramp up enforcement, create labor shortages, watch prices rise, then quietly relax enforcement when the pain gets bad enough. That cycle started in 1954, and we are still inside it.”

Listener Challenge

Andy Harvey, a police chief in Palestine, Pharr, and Dallas, makes the point I’d end on: crime rates in immigrant neighborhoods are low, and if the only witness to a serious crime is too frightened to talk to police, everyone in that community is less safe. 

Resources

⁠Loren Steffy⁠

⁠Stoney Creek Publishing⁠

Purchase ⁠Reconstructing Immigration⁠