Welcome to a review of all the Sherlock Holmes stories which are collected in the work, “The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes.” The appeared in the Strand Magazine from July 1891 to June 1892. Over 12 episodes, I will be reviewing each story and mine them for leadership, compliance and ethical lessons. In this episode, we consider “The Man with the Twisted Lip” which was originally published by the Strand Magazine in December 1891.
Summary
The story begins when Watson, called out by a friend Mrs. St. Clair, finds himself in an opium den in the East End of London. While attempting to extract his friend, he encounters Sherlock Holmes in disguise. Holmes is there on a different case involving Neville St. Clair, Mrs. St. Clair’s husband, who was reported missing under mysterious circumstances.
Mrs. St. Clair had seen her husband at a second story window of the opium den, distressed and quickly pulled away from the window. When she rushed to find him, the only people in the room were the landlord and a dirty, disfigured beggar known as Hugh Boone. Despite Boone’s rough exterior, he is known for his eloquence and wit.
Despite no evidence of foul play or indication of St. Clair being there, Mrs. St. Clair insists her husband was in the room. Holmes takes up the case and starts investigating, finding St. Clair’s clothes in the room, but no sign of the man himself.
Boone is arrested and put in a cell, where Holmes observes him closely. Eventually, Holmes discovers that Boone and Neville St. Clair are the same person. St. Clair, a respectable man with a previously high-paying job, had been leading a double life as the beggar Boone. He discovered that he could earn more money begging while disguised as the disfigured Boone, so he maintained this deception to support his family’s comfortable lifestyle.
St. Clair is extremely relieved to be found out, as he was tired of the lie but didn’t know how to get out of it without damaging his family’s reputation. In the end, it is decided that Boone’s ‘disappearance’ would be maintained to protect the family, and St. Clair vows to abandon his alter ego for good.
Compliance Lessons
1. Honesty and Transparency: The character Neville St. Clair disguises himself and leads a dual life, which eventually leads to misunderstandings and a temporary downfall. In leadership, being open, transparent, and honest is crucial. Leaders who hide important facts or issues from their teams can create mistrust and a lack of confidence.
2. Understand Different Perspectives: As a beggar, Neville St. Clair was able to understand a different section of society that he normally would not interact with. A good leader must strive to understand the different perspectives within their team, the broader organization, and the external market. This enhances decision-making and ensures that everyone feels heard and valued.
3. Adaptability: Despite his odd choice, St. Clair displayed a high degree of adaptability by successfully leading a double life. In leadership, circumstances often change rapidly, and the ability to adapt quickly and effectively is vital. Good leaders can handle uncertainty, make necessary adjustments, and guide their teams through changes.
4. The Importance of Brand: St. Clair manipulated his appearance to fit into different roles. While this is not advisable ethically, it does underscore the impact of a leader’s image on their followers. Leaders need to be mindful of how their behavior, attitude, and professionalism influence others.
5. Resilience: Despite the hardships he encountered in his double life, St. Clair demonstrated resilience. Leaders often face challenges and obstacles. The ability to bounce back, remain positive, and continue moving forward is a key leadership trait.
6. Integrity: The absence of integrity in St. Clair’s actions highlights the importance of this trait in leadership. Leaders must maintain high ethical standards and act in a way that is consistent with their words.
Resource
The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes
