Categories
FCPA Compliance Report

FCPA Compliance Report – AI, Data Compliance, and Ownership: A Conversation with Andrew Hopkins

Welcome to the award-winning FCPA Compliance Report, the longest-running podcast on compliance. In this episode, Tom welcomes Andrew Hopkins, President of PrivacyChain, to discuss the critical intersection of AI, data compliance, and data ownership.

Andrew brings his expertise from years of consulting, focusing on outcome-driven business support, and provides a comprehensive overview of the challenges and opportunities in managing and securing data in the age of AI. The conversation delves into the complexities of data security, the inefficiencies of traditional data management systems, and the potential of new technologies to enhance data governance and personal data ownership. Listeners will gain valuable insights into navigating the evolving landscape of data management and the importance of contextual integrity in AI processes.

Key highlights:

  • The Intersection of AI, Data Compliance, and Ownership
  • Challenges in Data Management and Compliance
  • Data Governance
  • Shortcomings of Current Data Management Systems
  • Data Integrity and Context

Resources:

Andrew Hopkins on LinkedIn

The Privacy Chain

Tom Fox

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

LinkedIn

Categories
Blog

Embracing the Unsexy Side of Data Analytics

In compliance, there is always excitement around the sleek dashboards, sophisticated visualizations, and predictive capabilities that data analytics bring. While these elements are undoubtedly valuable, compliance professionals must first navigate the decidedly “unsexy” side, the essential infrastructure and foundational aspects upon which these advanced capabilities rely. Matt Kelly and I recently explored this important yet overlooked aspect during a Compliance into the Weeds episode, emphasizing that without a robust underlying data infrastructure, even the most advanced analytics initiatives are doomed to fail. Our discussion was based on Kelly’s blog post on Radical Compliance.

The compliance function extends beyond measuring the effectiveness of our compliance programs. It entails understanding, assessing, and responding to the risks inherent within our broader organizations. These tasks require the correct data to be accurately captured, validated, and communicated effectively. Focusing only on end-stage analytics without addressing the foundational elements that feed these systems is akin to building a beautiful house without first laying a proper foundation. I wanted to explore these vital underpinnings and extract some practical lessons for today’s compliance professionals.

Lesson 1: Clearly Define Your Data Scope and Sources

The first crucial lesson delineates the data sources and scope for meaningful analytics. There are three critical groups of data stakeholders: the compliance function itself, business units (including both front-line operational teams and second-line functions such as HR, finance, and accounting), and the IT department responsible for data collection and management. Each entity provides a unique set of data relevant to compliance analytics. Compliance teams contribute oversight data related to compliance program performance and adherence; business units offer operational data reflecting day-to-day practices and processes; IT provides technological insights and system-generated records.

Understanding these data sets’ distinct nature and relevance allows compliance professionals to craft a focused data analytics strategy. A compliance officer who precisely defines what data is necessary will improve the accuracy and significance of analytics and streamline efforts to acquire and integrate this data. Furthermore, establishing clarity in the scope of required information and communicating this effectively fosters collaboration among various departments. This proactive communication reduces resistance, enhances cooperation, and ensures alignment across all parties, minimizing redundant data collection efforts or conflicting priorities. Defining the scope and source clearly from the outset is pivotal for long-term success in compliance analytics.

Lesson 2: Ensure Robust Data Validation and Reliability

Compliance analytics programs fundamentally depend on the robustness and reliability of the data feeding into analytic tools. No matter how advanced your AI or analytic models may be, the results generated rely entirely on the integrity of input data. (GIGO) Poor data invariably leads to misleading or erroneous conclusions, ultimately steering compliance teams down problematic pathways. This makes data validation an indispensable prerequisite rather than an afterthought.

Ensuring robust data validation and reliability means establishing systematic and meticulous processes to check for data accuracy, consistency, completeness, and timeliness. Compliance officers should prioritize working collaboratively with the business operations and IT departments to verify the integrity of the data at various collection points. Additionally, regular data audits and testing should become routine practice to detect inaccuracies or inconsistencies early. Proactive validation procedures, such as automated checks and regular reconciliations, help catch and rectify data quality issues before they can contaminate downstream analytic processes.

Given today’s rapid technological evolution, it is imperative that compliance teams continually adapt and refine their validation methodologies. Investing upfront resources and effort into rigorous validation practices ensures the sustainability and credibility of analytics-driven insights, making compliance analytics a trustworthy foundation for strategic decision-making and effective risk management.

Lesson 3: Navigate Change Management with Care

Change is constant in business, and the implications for compliance analytics can be significant whenever a business modifies its processes, systems, or technologies. Compliance analytics are highly sensitive to such shifts. Changes in business operations can disrupt previously reliable data streams, introduce inaccuracies, or necessitate entirely new types of data. This unpredictability represents a considerable risk, potentially turning carefully calibrated analytics pipelines into flawed sources of insights.

Compliance professionals must proactively integrate change management into their operational framework. Establishing clear protocols and robust channels of communication is paramount. Compliance teams should know upcoming processes, systems, or business practice changes. An established change management policy ensures that the analytics infrastructure can quickly adapt to business shifts without losing continuity or integrity in the data flow.

Compliance teams must regularly engage with business and IT units to anticipate possible disruptions and strategize solutions proactively. This might include altering data capture methods, updating analytic algorithms, or recalibrating analytic models to align with evolving realities. Effective change management protects the accuracy and usefulness of analytics and demonstrates compliance’s agility and responsiveness, reinforcing its critical strategic role within the broader organizational context.

Lesson 4: Cultivate Relationships with Key Data Stewards

Relationship-building with key data stewards within the organization is often overlooked but critical. Particularly in larger enterprises, master data management roles or teams serve as gatekeepers, responsible for overseeing, maintaining, and controlling data repositories that power analytics initiatives. Compliance officers must identify and actively cultivate relationships with these individuals, essential allies in accessing, structuring, and enhancing the data compliance teams need.

These relationships enable compliance officers to navigate bureaucratic obstacles more effectively, rapidly gain necessary approvals, and obtain access to critical data resources. Further, engaging with these stewards allows compliance professionals to leverage their technical expertise to fine-tune data structures and formats, facilitating more efficient and accurate analytic outcomes. In smaller or mid-sized companies, where such formalized roles may not exist, identifying the individuals who functionally fulfill these stewardship duties becomes even more vital. Personal rapport and trust-building can significantly expedite collaborative efforts in these scenarios.

Establishing strong, mutually beneficial relationships also fosters better responsiveness and support from these key stakeholders. Compliance teams can position themselves as partners who add reciprocal value, demonstrating how compliance-driven analytics address regulatory imperatives and provide strategic insights beneficial to broader organizational goals. This collaborative stance fosters lasting partnerships that empower compliance analytics and elevate the compliance function’s credibility across the organization.

Lesson 5: Align Compliance Data Analytics with Broader Business Objectives

Your compliance program must align your organization’s compliance analytics with the organization’s overall strategic goals and risk management framework. Compliance analytics should never operate in isolation but must directly support and complement broader business objectives. By integrating compliance risk management with enterprise-wide strategies, compliance professionals can ensure their analytics drive real organizational value, enhance risk mitigation capabilities, and facilitate informed decision-making processes.

Compliance professionals must articulate how compliance analytics directly align with and contribute to overarching business strategies and goals. Rather than framing analytics initiatives solely regarding regulatory compliance, professionals should present them as crucial tools for strategic business management. Compliance analytics can identify emerging risks, provide early warnings of operational inefficiencies, and generate insights that inform strategic and operational planning. Compliance officers secure stronger executive buy-in and cross-departmental support by linking compliance analytics initiatives to broader organizational imperatives such as improved operational efficiency, enhanced reputation management, reduced financial risk, and better-informed decision-making.

Moreover, this alignment facilitates greater transparency and cohesion within the organization. It ensures compliance analytics remain relevant, agile, and responsive as business objectives and external risk environments evolve. Positioning compliance analytics as an integral component of corporate strategy demonstrates compliance’s value as a regulatory necessity and a strategic business partner, fundamentally intertwined with the organization’s success.

Final Thoughts

Compliance professionals often gravitate toward the cutting-edge features of data analytics, and understandably so, predictive modeling, AI-driven insights, and dynamic visualizations are exciting and impactful tools. However, the equally critical foundational work required beneath these capabilities must be performed.

Compliance teams must give equal weight to the less glamorous but no less essential tasks of defining their data scopes, validating data reliability, managing changes adeptly, nurturing relationships with key data personnel, and aligning their analytic efforts with corporate objectives. Compliance professionals can build robust, effective programs that deliver real, lasting value by balancing the exciting potential of advanced analytics with disciplined attention to these fundamental infrastructure issues.

The compliance function that overlooks the “unsexy” details does so at its peril. After all, a dazzling analytics engine is worthless without the solid groundwork to support it. Let’s commit to embracing these foundational elements with the vigor and attention they deserve.

After all, the most powerful compliance insights often lie hidden beneath the surface in the careful, unglamorous cultivation of robust data infrastructure.

Categories
Compliance Tip of the Day

Compliance Tip of the Day – Data Analytics – The Foundational Work

Welcome to “Compliance Tip of the Day,” the podcast where we bring you daily insights and practical advice on navigating the ever-evolving landscape of compliance and regulatory requirements. Whether you’re a seasoned compliance professional or just starting your journey, we aim to provide bite-sized, actionable tips to help you stay on top of your compliance game. Join us as we explore the latest industry trends, share best practices, and demystify complex compliance issues to keep your organization on the right side of the law. Tune in daily for your dose of compliance wisdom, and let’s make compliance a little less daunting, one tip at a time.

Compliance professionals often gravitate toward the cutting-edge features of data analytics. However, the equally critical foundational work required beneath these capabilities must be performed.

Categories
Compliance Into the Weeds

Compliance into the Weeds: Unsexy Keys to Data Analytics for Compliance Programs

The award-winning Compliance into the Weeds is the only weekly podcast that takes a deep dive into a compliance-related topic, literally going into the weeds to explore a subject more fully. Are you looking for some hard-hitting insights on compliance? Look no further than Compliance into the Weeds! In this Compliance into the Weeds episode, Tom Fox and Matt Kelly take a deep dive into the critical yet often overlooked aspects of data analytics.

They discuss Matt’s recent blog post on the ‘Unsexy Keys to Data Analytics,’ emphasizing the importance of foundational infrastructure over flashy visualizations. The conversation covers the need for robust data validation, the cooperation between compliance, business units, and IT departments, and the challenges faced by compliance officers in smaller companies. Highlights include real-world examples, the role of data governance, and how to align compliance risk management with corporate objectives amid ever-changing business landscapes.

Key highlights:

  • The Importance of Data Infrastructure
  • Compliance vs. Enterprise Data Analytics
  • Collaboration Across Departments
  • Data Governance and Change Management
  • Aligning Compliance with Corporate Risk Management

Resources:

Matt in Radical Compliance

Tom

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

LinkedIn

Compliance into the Weeds was recently honored as one of the Top 25 Regulatory Compliance Podcast.

Categories
31 Days to More Effective Compliance Programs

31 Days to a More Effective Compliance Program: Day 29 – Enhancing Compliance through Automation

Welcome to a special podcast series on the Compliance Podcast Network, 31 Days to a More Effective Compliance Program. Over these 31 days of the series in January 2025, Tom Fox will post a key part of a best practices compliance program daily. By the end of January, you will have enough information to create, design, or enhance a compliance program. Each podcast will be short, at 6–8 minutes, and will include three key takeaways you can implement at little or no cost to help update your compliance program. I hope you will join us each day in January for this exploration of best practices in compliance.

Traditional compliance reporting methods, often reliant on manual processes like Excel spreadsheets, are time-consuming and prone to errors. This episode explores how Chief Compliance Officers and compliance professionals can enhance their programs through automation. By adopting data-driven solutions and leveraging regulatory operations (Reg Ops), it’s possible to provide near real-time reporting and improve decision-making efficiency. The focus is on integrating existing security and compliance tools, gathering real-time evidence, automating compliance gap tickets, and generating comprehensive reports for stakeholders. However, challenges like balancing data accuracy and security and the cultural transformation required for adopting these new practices are critical considerations. Embracing data-driven compliance can help organizations modernize and keep pace with the evolving regulatory landscape.

Key highlights:

  • Challenges in Traditional Compliance Reporting
  • The Role of Reg Ops in Compliance
  • Integrating Tools for Real-Time Compliance

Resources:

Click here to receive a 20% discount on The Compliance Handbook, 5th edition, for listeners to this podcast.

Categories
31 Days to More Effective Compliance Programs

31 Days to a More Effective Compliance Program: Day 1-Data Driven Compliance

Welcome to a special podcast series on the Compliance Podcast Network, 31 Days to a More Effective Compliance Program. Over these 31 days series in January 2025, I will post a key part a best practices compliance program each day. By the end of January, you will have enough information to create, design or enhancement a compliance program. Each podcast will be short, at 6-8 minutes with three key takeaways that you can implement at little or no cost to help update your compliance program. I hope you will plan to join each day in January for this exploration of best practices in compliance.

In the first episode of ‘One Month to a More Effective Compliance Program’, host Tom Fox, the Compliance Evangelist, emphasizes the increasing importance of data analytics and monitoring in the realm of compliance. Highlighting insights from the DOJ, this episode illustrates how data-driven compliance can significantly improve decision-making, business efficiency, and risk management. By leveraging technology and effective data analysis, companies can uncover hidden issues such as improper payments and improve overall corporate transparency. Tom Fox discusses the necessity for compliance programs to have quick and easy access to data to ensure informed decision-making and proactive compliance management.

Key Highlights

  • Importance of Data Analytics in Compliance
  • Implementing Data-Driven Compliance
  • Challenges and Solutions in Data-Driven Compliance

Resources

Listeners to this podcast can receive a 20% discount to The Compliance Handbook, 5th edition by clicking here.

Categories
Compliance Tip of the Day

Compliance Tip of the Day – Boards and Digital Transformation of Compliance

Welcome to “Compliance Tip of the Day,” the podcast where we bring you daily insights and practical advice on navigating the ever-evolving landscape of compliance and regulatory requirements. Whether you’re a seasoned compliance professional or just starting your journey, we aim to provide bite-sized, actionable tips to help you stay on top of your compliance game. Join us as we explore the latest industry trends, share best practices, and demystify complex compliance issues to keep your organization on the right side of the law. Tune in daily for your dose of compliance wisdom, and let’s make compliance a little less daunting, one tip at a time.

The Board can help lead the digital transformation of compliance.

For more information on the Ethico Toolkit for Middle Managers, available at no charge, click here.

Check out the entire 3-book series, The Compliance Kids, on Amazon.com.

Categories
Compliance Tip of the Day

Compliance Tip of the Day: Why Data Access is Key to Compliance Effectiveness

Welcome to “Compliance Tip of the Day,” the podcast where we bring you daily insights and practical advice on navigating the ever-evolving landscape of compliance and regulatory requirements.

Whether you’re a seasoned compliance professional or just starting your journey, our aim is to provide you with bite-sized, actionable tips to help you stay on top of your compliance game.

Join us as we explore the latest industry trends, share best practices, and demystify complex compliance issues to keep your organization on the right side of the law.

Tune in daily for your dose of compliance wisdom, and let’s make compliance a little less daunting, one tip at a time.

Today, we explore why the DOJ will now evaluate whether compliance teams have adequate access to the necessary data to assess the effectiveness of their programs.

Categories
Compliance Into the Weeds

Compliance into the Weeds: The 2024 ECCP Update on Data Access

The award winning, Compliance into the Weeds is the only weekly podcast that takes a deep dive into a compliance-related topic, literally going into the weeds to more fully explore a subject. Looking for some hard-hitting insights on compliance? Look no further than Compliance into the Weeds!

In this episode, Tom Fox and Matt Kelly take a deep dive into the 2024 update to the Department of Justice’s guidelines for corporate compliance programs, focusing on data and data access.

Tom and Matt explore the significance of these updates and whether they stem from companies showing advancements in data analytics or the DOJ recognizing gaps in data access for compliance officers. The discussion highlights the challenges compliance officers face, especially with diverse ERP systems and data silos, and provides insights into how compliance officers can leverage these guidelines to advocate for better data access within their organizations. The episode also breaks down specific questions from the DOJ’s guidelines, offering practical advice on addressing obstacles to data, resources for data access, and data maintenance.

Key Highlights:

  • The Importance of Data Access in Compliance
  • Challenges in Data Access for Compliance Officers
  • DOJ’s Six Key Questions on Data Access
  • Addressing Data Access Impediments
  • Tools and Resources for Data Analytics
  • Communicating with the Board on Data Analytics

Resources:

Matt in Radical Compliance

Tom in the FCPA Compliance and Ethics Blog

Tom

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

LinkedIn

Categories
Blog

Argentieri Speech and 2024 ECCP: Data Access and Data Analytics

Deputy Assistant Attorney General Nicole M. Argentieri’s speech highlighted a critical shift in the DOJ’s approach to evaluating corporate compliance programs. As outlined in the updated 2024 Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs (2024 ECCP), the emphasis on data access signals a new era where compliance professionals are expected to wield data with the same rigor and sophistication as their business counterparts.

In her remarks, Argentieri said, “Third, under the updated ECCP, our prosecutors will assess whether a compliance program has appropriate access to data, including to assess its effectiveness. We have added questions about whether compliance personnel have adequate access to relevant data sources and the assets, resources, and technology available to compliance and risk management personnel. As part of this assessment, we will also consider whether companies are putting the same resources and technology into gathering and leveraging data for compliance purposes they use in their business.”

Her remarks were paired with new language in the 2024 ECCP, which stated:

Data Resources and Access – Do compliance and control personnel have sufficient direct or indirect access to relevant data sources for timely and effective monitoring and/or testing of policies, controls, and transactions? Do any impediments exist that limit or delay access to relevant data sources, and if so, what is the company doing to address the impediments? Do compliance personnel know of and have the means to access all relevant data sources reasonably timely? Is the company appropriately leveraging data analytics tools to create efficiencies in compliance operations and measure the effectiveness of components of compliance programs? How is the company managing the quality of its data sources? How does the company measure the accuracy, precision, or recall of any data analytics models it uses?

Proportionate Resource Allocation – How do the assets, resources, and technology available to compliance and risk management compare to those available elsewhere in the company? Is there an imbalance between the technology and resources used by the company to identify and capture market opportunities and the technology and resources used to detect and mitigate risks?

The speech and the 2024 ECCP put new and additional requirements around a corporate compliance program in the areas of data and data analytics. But how exactly should compliance teams navigate these heightened expectations? Here’s what you must do to ensure your compliance program meets these new standards.

Evaluate Your Data Access to Ensure Unimpeded Access to Relevant Data

The first step in aligning with the DOJ’s expectations is to conduct a comprehensive audit of your current data access. Compliance professionals must ask:

  • Conduct a Data Access Audit. Identify all the critical data sources for monitoring and testing your compliance policies, controls, and transactions. This includes financial transactions, communications, third-party interactions, and other data relevant to your risk profile.
  • Identify and Eliminate Barriers. Once you have a map of your data landscape, scrutinize it for any impediments that may limit or delay access to critical data. These barriers could be technical, such as legacy systems that do not integrate well, or organizational, like departmental silos that restrict data flow. Develop a plan to remove these impediments, whether through technology upgrades, process improvements, or changes in data governance.
  • Educate and Empower Compliance Teams. It is not enough for data to be accessible; your compliance personnel must also have the knowledge and tools to access it effectively. Invest in training programs that enhance data literacy among your team members, ensuring they can navigate and leverage data to its full potential.

The DOJ will scrutinize whether your compliance team has the same data visibility as other business units. If you find gaps, now is the time to bridge them.

Assess Resource Allocation for Data Analytics

Argentieri’s remarks also underscore the importance of resourcing. It is more than having data; your corporate compliance function must have the tools and talent to analyze it effectively. The 2024 ECCP emphasizes the importance of using data analytics tools to create efficiencies in compliance operations and measure the effectiveness of compliance programs.

  • Technology Investment. Are you using advanced analytics tools? Leverage AI and machine learning to proactively identify patterns, anomalies, and potential compliance risks.
  • Invest specifically in Advanced Analytics Tools. Ensure that your compliance program is equipped with state-of-the-art data analytics tools. These tools should be capable of processing large volumes of data, identifying patterns, and flagging potential risks in real-time. Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) can be particularly useful in predictive analytics, helping you stay ahead of emerging risks.
  • Human Resources. Do you have data-savvy compliance professionals on your team? Consider upskilling current staff or hiring data analysts who understand the technical and regulatory landscapes.
  • Benchmark Resources Across the Organization. Start by comparing the assets, resources, and technology available to your compliance and risk management teams with those available in other departments, particularly those focused on capturing market opportunities. Look for any imbalances that could undermine the effectiveness of your compliance efforts.
  • Make a case for compliance. If compliance is underresourced, build a compelling business case for increased investment. Highlight the risks associated with inadequate compliance resources, including the potential for regulatory breaches, reputational damage, and financial losses. Use data to demonstrate how enhanced resources could improve compliance outcomes and protect the organization.

Implement Real-Time Monitoring

The DOJ’s focus on data access and analytics also means that real-time monitoring should be a cornerstone of your compliance strategy. Static, periodic reviews are no longer sufficient.

  • Continuous Data Feeds. Implement systems that provide compliance officers with ongoing, real-time data. This allows for immediate detection of potential issues.
  • Automated Alerts. Set up automated alerts for key risk indicators, such as unusual transaction patterns or policy violations. This ensures that your team can respond to potential breaches before they escalate.
  • Integrate Compliance into Business Strategy. To ensure ongoing support, integrate compliance more closely with business strategy. Show how robust compliance efforts contribute to long-term success, aligning compliance goals with the company’s objectives.

Leverage Data to Assess Compliance Program Effectiveness

The ultimate goal of data access and analytics is to measure and improve the effectiveness of your compliance program. The DOJ is looking for companies that can demonstrate how they use data to inform their compliance efforts.

  • KPIs and Metrics. Develop key performance indicators (KPIs) that track compliance program success. Metrics might include the number of detected compliance incidents, response times, or the effectiveness of training programs.
  • Data-Driven Adjustments. Use data insights to make real-time adjustments to your compliance strategy. If the data shows a particular area of concern, pivot quickly and address it with targeted interventions.
  • Measure the Effectiveness of Analytics Models. Develop metrics to evaluate the performance of your data analytics models. These could include detection rates, false positive/negative ratios, and the speed at which issues are identified and resolved. Review and refine these models to ensure they deliver accurate and actionable insights.

Ensure Transparency and Documentation

Finally, remember that the DOJ will be looking for transparency. Be prepared to demonstrate how you use data, make decisions, and allocate resources.

  • Document, Document, Document. Keep thorough records of your data access, analysis processes, and any adjustments based on data insights.
  • Audit Trails. Maintain clear audit trails that show how data influenced compliance decisions. This will be critical in demonstrating to the DOJ that your program is reactive and proactively leveraging data to prevent compliance failures.
  • Monitor Data Quality. High-quality data is the backbone of effective compliance. Regularly assess the quality of your data sources, checking for accuracy, precision, and recall. Implement data governance frameworks that ensure data integrity and reliability, ensuring your analytics models are based on the best available data.

Finally, under Part III of the 2024 ECCP, in the section entitled, Does the Corporation’s Compliance Program Work in Practice?, the DOJ said prosecutors would pose the following question, “Prosecutors should also assess how the company has leveraged its  data to gain insights into the effectiveness of its compliance program and otherwise sought to  promote an organizational culture that encourages ethical conduct and a commitment to  compliance with the law.”

Coupling that language from the 2024 ECCP with Nicole Argentieri’s speech, you see a clarion call for compliance professionals to elevate their programs through the availability and utilization of data and data analytics to meet the DOJ’s evolving expectations. The message is clear: data is not just a business asset but a compliance imperative. By ensuring unimpeded and robust data access, investing in analytics, implementing real-time monitoring, leveraging data to assess program effectiveness, and achieving resource parity for compliance, your compliance program will meet the DOJ’s standards and drive greater organizational integrity and resilience. In this new era of data-driven compliance, the key to success lies in strategic investment and proactive management.

The stakes have never been higher, but with the right approach, the rewards—reducing risk and increasing trust—are worth the effort.