Categories
Blog

Never the Same: Part 1 – Why Supply Chain Will Never Be the Same After the Russian Invasion

After the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the world of business will never be the same again. Deputy Attorney General (DAG) Lisa Monaco recently said that the world’s “geopolitical landscape is more challenging and complex than ever. The most prominent example is of course Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.” It is “nothing less than a fundamental challenge to international norms, sovereignty and the rule of law that underpins our society.” This is even more so in the current business climate.
Over this five-part series, I will consider how business will never again be the same and how a confluence of events has changed business forever. I am joined in this exploration by Brandon Daniels, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Exiger. We will explore the irrevocable changes in Supply Chain, trade and economic sanctions, anti-corruption, cyber-security and environmental, social and governance (ESG). In Part 1, we begin with changes in the supply chain as there may well be no area of businesses which has experienced the tectonic shifts that have occurred in the marketplace over the past couple of years than in Supply Chain.
Daniels identified three key reasons for these shifts. The first began with the realization of the untenable actions of the major player on the US supply chain, China. This realization had begun pre-pandemic, when it became clear of the massive theft of US intellectual property by Chinese businesses which led to a huge counterfeit goods problem coming out of China. Daniels estimated that “70% of the world’s counterfeit market is driven by China.” The second was the slave labor issue with China, particularly the Uyghurs. This extensive use of slave labor gave China an economic advantage which in many cases could not be overcome. It was economic warfare by another name.
All of this was exacerbated by the pandemic and we saw what it meant to have an economic and geopolitical adversary as one of your key suppliers during a true worldwide healthcare crisis. This confluence of events led to several key changes in thinking about supply chain. First, supply chain efficacy is not about weather events, it is not about logistics, it is not about just in time. There are much broader sets of issues for supply chain that had not come to the fore previously but came much more clearly into focus, such as geopolitical tensions. According to Daniels, “we realized that supply chain is multifaceted in terms of issues.”
Next came the recognition of the need for more and greater government oversight and regulation. The need to stamp out modern slavery led to the passage of the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act. This law significantly expanded compliance requirements for companies to certify that goods made with forced labor in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region of the People’s Republic of China do not enter the United States. Interestingly, the law created the presumption that all goods produced in Xinjiang were produced using forced labor, with the burden of proof resting on companies to demonstrate that materials, parts, and goods originating in China were not mined, produced, or manufactured wholly or in part in Xinjiang. There was also a business and government realization that many of the key rare earth elements and minerals widely used in US manufacturing process came from China and now Russia.
Daniels put all of this into perspective when he said, “you had this big earthquake in the pandemic, but then you had all these fault lines that we didn’t realize that were on the edge of a precipice. We were in these really brittle places and just all fell apart with the Russian invasion of Ukraine. From rare earth elements like neodymium which is used in securing a F35 to electric car batteries, to metals and heavy metals used in standard manufacturing processes such as aluminum, iron and neon; supply chain disruptions were all acerbated by the Russian invasion of Ukraine on top of the ongoing disruptions from the pandemic and beyond.”
Finally, was a new element to the supply chain calculus, what Daniels termed “the ethical conundrum.” Russia has engaged in a brutal unjustified war that has disrupted the flow of goods and services from both Russia and Ukraine. Neon, a key element for processing chips, is heavily concentrated in Ukraine as are some of our largest outsourced engineering software companies. As the US and EU governments have responded with a series of harsher and more robust economic and trade sanctions the pressures on supply chain have increased. You must look at greater and more ongoing due diligence and greater sustainability.
These issues have moved beyond simply national security issues in the governmental and public sector. As DAG Monaco said, “Increasingly, you and your clients are on the front lines in responding to these geopolitical realities…our goal is not only to hold people accountable, but to disrupt these threats using all the tools available to us.” Private companies must understand they are now a part of what Daniels characterized as “continuous non-kinetic warfare.”
But in addition to this new type of warfare of which every business is now a part of going forward, it all ties back to US economic prosperity. While this was clear in the US adversarial relationship with China pre-pandemic; it accelerated during the pandemic and now after the Russian invasion of Ukraine. If you could not get a mask so that you could go to work during the pandemic, that health issue became an economic issue. If you were doing business with a Russian oligarch, the reputational damage to your top line will negatively impact your company, perhaps in a material manner.
Tomorrow we consider why economic and trade sanctions will never be the same.

Categories
Daily Compliance News

June 18, 2022 the MD Dishes on Goldman Edition


In today’s edition of Daily Compliance News:

  • Vince McMahon steps down as head of WWE. (NYT)
  • The current Peruvian President is under investigation for corruption. (WaPo)
  • Former Goldman MD attacks firm in an upcoming book. (Bloomberg)
  • DOJ wants companies to self-report sanctions violations. (WSJ)
Categories
Innovation in Compliance

Compliance Insights from Traliant: Episode 4 – Scott Schneider, Spotlight on Your Code of Conduct


Welcome to a special five-part podcast series on compliance insights, sponsored by Traliant. Over this series, we will discuss key issues that Traliant is helping to lead and define the online training industry going forward. Over this five-part series, I will visit with  John Arendes, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) at the company, on what is new at New Traliant and what the Department of Justice (DOJ) has communicated to the compliance community regarding its expectations around online training and communications; Maggie Smith, Vice President of Human Resources at Traliant on the role of DEI in your corporate ESG program; and Scott Schneider, Head of Content Development at Traliant on your Code of Conduct and anti-corruption training. In this Episode 4, I visit with Scott Schneider, VP of Innovation at Traliant, on the evolution and importance of the corporate Code of Conduct. Highlights include:

  • Culture is the key driver, and your Code of Conduct is the foundation for a broader discussion of what regulators look for in a compliance program.
  • How has the Code of Conduct evolved?
  • Your Code of Conduct should be more than simply aspirational, and your Code of Conduct training helps drive home values, ethics & culture.

Resources
Traliant Website
Scott Schneider on LinkedIn

Categories
Innovation in Compliance

Compliance Insights from Traliant: Episode 2-John Arendes on What the DOJ Wants

Welcome to a special five-part podcast series on compliance insights, sponsored by Traliant. Over this series, we will discuss key issues that Traliant is helping to lead and define the online training industry in going forward. Over this five part series I will visit with  John Arendes, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) at the company on what is new at New Traliant and what the Department of Justice (DOJ) has communicated to the compliance community regarding its expectations around online training and communications; Maggie Smith, Vice President of Human Resources at Traliant on the role of DEI in your corporate ESG program; and Scott Schneider, Head of Content Development at Traliant on your Code of Conduct and anti-corruption training. In this Episode 2, I visit with John Arendes on DOJ communications around its expectations for training.  Highlights include:

  • In DAG Lisa Monaco’s October 2021 speech, she said the DOJ would focus on corporate culture as a key indicia of compliance.
  • The DOJ has made clear that while longer form online training is satisfactory, they expect companies to develop short, direct compliance training for employees.
  • Since the release of the Evaluation of Effective Compliance Programs, the DOJ has mandated, effective and targeted compliance training.

Resources
Traliant Website
John Arendes on LinkedIn

Categories
Blog

DOJ Training Expectations

Welcome to a special five-part blog post series on the New Traliant, sponsored by Traliant, LLC. Over this series, we will discuss key issues that Traliant is helping to lead and define the online training industry in going forward. I will visit with John Arendes, Chief Executive Officer (CEO), on what is new at Traliant and what the Department of Justice (DOJ) has communicated to the compliance community regarding its expectations around online training and communications; Maggie Smith, Vice President of Human Resources, on the role of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) in your corporate environmental, social and governance (ESG) program; and Scott Schneider, Head of Content Development, on your Code of Conduct and anti-corruption training. In Episode 2, I visit with John Arendes on DOJ communications around its expectations for training.
There have been multiple communications from the regulators over the past couple of years about what they expect in training, first at the federal level from the DOJ and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and second at the stage level as many state regulators have also communicated what their expectations are around training. Last October, the Deputy Attorney General (DAG) Lisa Monaco gave a speech where she announced changes under the Biden administration’s DOJ enforcement of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) and other white-collar crimes. For the first time the DOJ talked about corporate culture, and Monaco said that companies and compliance officers need to assess culture. Moreover, the DOJ would look at a company’s culture in an enforcement action.
All of this means that companies must strengthen their training and communications. Arendes said, “when you look at the very top of an issue it is always stemming from a culture at the top of an organization.” He believes culture should be inclusive, diverse and respectful. This means moving beyond the standard or even traditional ‘check-the-box’ training. This DOJ assessment of corporate culture will require companies go “beyond just checking the box.” Companies need training which offers practical advice, case studies, and address real life scenarios.
This is key to Traliant training, “it’s based on real life. When we talk with our customers, they also say to us and communicate, here’s our culture and here’s what we’re trying to get to. How do you help us with that?” The Traliant approach is to create an entire program of courses that interlocks to each other, to create a learning and engagement experience that we hope will help a company in either changing their culture or reinforcing it, in a documented effective manner.
Another key that Arendes mentioned for anyone evaluating online training is the granularity of the training. For instance, basic discrimination and harassment training for the healthcare community is different for the restaurant environment. You should begin with your vertical, or specific training. In healthcare that would be training based on the healthcare environment. This means your training is targeted right to the audience. From there you should look for the creation of scenarios with different job positions, doing those different scenarios. Arendes provided the example of a nurse, working with a doctor is different from a receptionist working with the doctor.
We concluded with a discussion of the DOJ mandate for shorter, more focused compliance communications as a supplement to deeper dive training. Here the Traliant approach is called ‘Spark’. In this approach, the training is designed to ‘spark’ a conversation. Organizations will periodically use such communications to challenge the entire organization which can facilitate ongoing conversations about specific aspects of culture. From DEI to safety to ESG, to doing business ethically and in compliance. This also fits directly into the DOJ prescription of short, focused communications which can be effective. These can also be well documented so that if a regulator comes knocking you can quickly and efficiently demonstrate targeted, effective communications.
While Arendes cautioned that such short, focused training should not be seen as a deep drive or comprehensive training, it can supplement deeper and richer training. Shorter training can work well to reinforce deeper training. You can roll out these shorter trainings at multiple times throughout the year to “give reinforcement to spark these conversations.” He concluded, here at Traliant, “We have a whole standard library of those that come right out on the box with our library subscription and people are using them continuously, to do this reinforcement throughout the year. Based on their effectiveness and this new DOJ approach, I see those becoming more and more important to compliance programs.”
Join us for our next episode where we look at DEI training.
Check out the podcast with John Arendes this blog post is based upon here.

Categories
Everything Compliance

Episode 101, the Glencore Edition


Welcome to the only roundtable podcast in compliance as we celebrate our second century of shows. In 2021, Everything Compliance was honored by W3 as a top talk show in podcasting. In this episode, we have the quintet of Jonathan Marks, Karen Woody, Jonathan Armstrong, Tom Fox and Matt Kelly. In this episode, we take up the Glencore FCPA settlement. We conclude with our fan favorite Shout Outs and Rants.

1. Karen Woody takes a deep dive into the history of Glencore, from its founding by Marc Rich in the 1980s through the allegations of bribery, corruption and market manipulation which led to the FCPA and CFTC settlements.  Woody shouts out the US National and state parks systems which provide much needed green spaces for Americans.

2. Matt Kelly takes a deep dive into CCO certification issue and what it might mean for individual CCO criminal liability going forward.  Kelly has a dual shout out and rant. He shouts out to the Boston Celtics for having the greatest NBA Finals-Game 1 comeback to win the game. He rants about the DOJ failing to post the speech by AAG Kenneth Polite where he announced the new requirement for CCO certification.

3. Jonathan Marks explores the role of internal audit in contributing to the compliance failures and what IA can do to facilitate a culture change at the company. Marks also has a dual shout out and rant. He shouts out to the Philadelphia Phillies for firing manager Joe Girardi and rants about Glencore’s Press Release about their updated compliance which he rants “says nothing”.

4. Tom Fox considers the dual monitor aspect of the resolution and the requirements of the monitorships. Fox reads out the names of the students and teachers who were killed in the recent massacre in Uvalde,  TX.

5. Jonathan Armstrong explores the settlement from the UK perspective and considers, what if any charges against individuals that the UK-Serious Fraud Office might bring. Armstrong shouts out to the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee and Sir Andy Murray for speaking out against the murder of school children. Murray is a survivor of a similar event in Scotland.

The members of the Everything Compliance are:
•       Jay Rosen– Jay is Vice President, Business Development Corporate Monitoring at Affiliated Monitors. Rosen can be reached at JRosen@affiliatedmonitors.com
•       Karen Woody – One of the top academic experts on the SEC. Woody can be reached at kwoody@wlu.edu
•       Matt Kelly – Founder and CEO of Radical Compliance. Kelly can be reached at mkelly@radicalcompliance.com
•       Jonathan Armstrong –is our UK colleague, who is an experienced data privacy/data protection lawyer with Cordery in London. Armstrong can be reached at jonathan.armstrong@corderycompliance.com
•       Jonathan Marks is Partner, Firm Practice Leader – Global Forensic, Compliance & Integrity Services at Baker Tilly. Marks can be reached at jonathan.marks@bakertilly.com

The host and producer, ranter (and sometime panelist) of Everything Compliance is Tom Fox the Voice of Compliance. He can be reached at tfox@tfoxlaw.com. Everything Compliance is a part of the Compliance Podcast Network.

Categories
Daily Compliance News

June 9, 2022 the FBI Sued Edition


In today’s edition of Daily Compliance News:

  • DOJ hires HP CCO to run Fraud Section. (WSJ)
  • Hui Chen moves to R&G Insights Lab. (WSJ)
  • Gymnasts sue FBI for $1bn. (WSJ)
  • New SEC rules on equity trades. (WSJ)
Categories
FCPA Compliance Report

Scott Schneider on Your Code of Conduct

In this episode of the FCPA Compliance Report I visit with Scott Schneider, Head of Content Development at Traliant. Scott has been in the compliance space for over 15 years and is passionate about the building blocks of a best practices compliance program, including Codes of Conduct. This week we take a deep dive into the foundational backbone of every compliance program, the Code of Conduct.  Some of the highlights include:

·      Importance of  Code of Conduct training.

·      Types of Code training.

·      Why have a Code of Conduct?

·      How does a Code of Conduct help establish culture?

·      Key areas the Code should cover?

·      How should a company develop its Code of Conduct?

·      When should a Code be revisited or reassessed?

·      The roles of Codes of Conduct and training down the road into 2025 and beyond?

Resources

Scott Schneider on LinkedIn
Traliant website

Categories
Blog

Glencore Resolution: Part IV – The Resolution

Last week, the Attorney General and a host of other Department of Justice (DOJ) officials announced the settlement of a massive Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) and market manipulation case against Glencore plc (Glencore). Over this blog series, I have been reviewing the matter and mining it for lessons learned for the compliance community. Today, in Part IV, we take a dive into the settlement itself.
According to the DOJ Press Release, Glencore pled guilty to one count of conspiracy to violate the FCPA, agreed to a criminal fine of $428,521,173, and acknowledged criminal forfeiture liability in the amount of $272,185,792. Glencore also had charges brought against it by the UK Serious Fraud Office (SFO) and reached separate parallel resolutions with the Brazilian Ministério Público Federal (MPF). The DOJ agreed to credit the company over $256 million in payments that it makes to the CFTC, to the Court in the UK as well as to authorities in Switzerland, in the event that the company reaches a resolution with Swiss authorities within one year.
In a Market Manipulation case, separate and apart from the FCPA enforcement action, Glencore admitted to a muti-year scheme to manipulate fuel oil prices at two of the busiest commercial shipping ports in the United States. Under the terms of the Commodities Future Trading Commission (CFTC) resolution, the company will pay a criminal fine of $341,221,682 and criminal forfeiture of $144,417,203. Under the terms of the Plea Agreement, the DOJ will credit over $242 million in payments that the company makes to the CFTC.
In other words, there was some serious misconduct going on here, for multiple years, in multiple countries with multiple schemes. Yet Glencore received a reduction of 15% based upon the FCPA Corporate Enforcement Policy and a 2-point reduction in the overall penalty calculation under the US Sentencing Guidelines. Both of these discounts led to a not-insignificant reduction from the overall penalty assessed.
First let us take up the areas that did not avail itself of under the FCPA Corporate Enforcement Policy. Glencore did not receive voluntary disclosure credit because it failed to self-disclose its legal violations to the DOJ. Although Glencore received partial cooperation credit, it did not receive full credit because it did not always “demonstrate a full commitment” to cooperation, was slow in providing documents and other evidence and was slow in its remediation. Additionally, it did not timely and appropriately remediate with respect to disciplining certain employees involved in the misconduct.
Moreover, Glencore did not have adequate internal controls in place at the time of the underlying incidents took place. Since that time, Glencore has taken remedial measures, certain of the compliance enhancements are new and have not been fully implemented or tested to demonstrate that they would prevent and detect similar misconduct in the future, mandating the imposition of an independent compliance monitor for a term of three years.
Even with these failures, Glencore received a substantial reduction of what it could have been required to pay. Based upon the calculations in the Plea Agreement, I estimate the total discount was in the range of $100 million.
Glencore agreed to continue to cooperate with the DOJ in ongoing investigations and prosecutions relating to the underlying misconduct, to modify its compliance program where necessary. The DOJ cited several additional factors crediting Glencore’s compliance remediation efforts, including (a) Glencore’s implementation of a centralized compliance function, hiring of a Chief Compliance Officer (CCO), and significantly increasing the compliance staff; (b) enhancing its business partner management, reducing the number of third-party representatives, adopting payment controls and post-engagement monitoring controls; and (c) investing in increased compliance headcount and data analytics.
Glencore itself, in a Press Release issued the day of the announced settlements, touted new additions to its compliance program. The company said that it has “bolstered its compliance structures and controls through a comprehensive programme built around risk assessment, policies, procedures, standards and guidelines based on international best practice, associated training and awareness initiatives as well as monitoring systems.” These initiatives included:

  • Strengthening the Group’s Code of Conduct and launching a comprehensive global awareness and training campaign designed to embed Glencore’s Values throughout its business, set expectations and ensure accountability for all employees;
  • Establishing a centralized, independent and empowered compliance function and, in 2020, appointing a new dedicated Head of Compliance;
  • Making a significant investment in compliance systems and resources, as well as experienced personnel;
  • Significantly enhancing and expanding the Group’s ethics and compliance training programs;
  • Instituting a comprehensive business partner management programme, including significantly reducing the Company’s use of third-party business generating intermediaries and employing end-to-end controls to oversee their engagement;
  • Implementing extensive monitoring and testing mechanisms, including through the use of data analytics, to assess whether our controls are entrenched and effective across the Group and ensure continuous improvement; and
  • Engaging leading external advisors to review Glencore’s systems and verify that controls are working as intended.

It appears quite a bit of work went into not simply cleaning up Glencore but in improving its overall culture. Of course, there is quite a bit of work do and that will no doubt turn in large part on the effectiveness of the monitor. More on that and final thoughts in our next post.

Categories
Blog

Glencore Resolution: Part III – The Commodity Price Manipulation Case

Last week, the Attorney General and a host of other Department of Justice (DOJ) officials announced the settlement of a massive Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) and market manipulation case against Glencore plc (Glencore). Over the next several blog posts, I will be reviewing the matter and mining it for lessons learned for the compliance community. Today, in Part III, we take a detour into the Commodity Price Manipulation Case and see how this matter should be studied by compliance professional.
In this case separate and apart from the FCPA enforcement action, Glencore admitted to a muti-year scheme to manipulate fuel oil prices at two of the busiest commercial shipping ports in the United States. Under the terms of the Commodities Future Trading Commission (CFTC) resolution, the company will pay a criminal fine of $341,221,682 and criminal forfeiture of $144,417,203. Under the terms of the Plea Agreement, the DOJ will credit over $242 million in payments that the company makes to the CFTC.
According to the CFTC Press Release, Glencore’s manipulative and fraudulent conduct—including conduct relating to foreign corruption—defrauded its counterparties, harmed other market participants, and undermined the integrity of the US and global physical and derivatives oil markets. Platts physical oil benchmarks, including those that were the subject of Glencore’s manipulative conduct, serve as price benchmarks for end-users and market participants, and are incorporated as reference prices for the settlement of numerous derivatives. (For a copy of the CFTC Order, see link in the CFTC Press Release.)
According to the CFTC Order, Glencore had a global commodity trading business, which included trading in fuel oil. Between approximately January 2011 and August 2019, Glencore conspired to manipulate two benchmark price assessments published by S&P Global Platts (Platts) for fuel oil products, specifically intermediate fuel oil 380 CST at the Port of Los Angeles (Los Angeles Fuel) and RMG 380 fuel oil at the Port of Houston (US Gulf Coast Fuel Oil). The Port of Los Angeles is the busiest shipping port in the US by container volume. The Port of Houston is the largest US port on the Gulf Coast and the busiest port in the US by foreign waterborne tonnage.
As part of the conspiracy, Glencore employees sought to unlawfully enrich themselves and the company, by increasing profits and reducing costs on contracts to buy and sell physical fuel oil, as well as certain derivative positions the company held. The price terms of the physical contracts and derivative positions were set by reference to daily benchmark price assessments published by Platts—either Los Angeles Fuel or US Gulf Coast Fuel Oil—on a certain day or days plus or minus a fixed premium. On these pricing days, Glencore employees submitted orders to buy and sell (bids and offers) to Platts during the daily trading “window” for the Platts price assessments with the intent to artificially push the price assessment up or down.
In an example from the CFTC Order, if Glencore had a contract to buy fuel oil, employees submitted offers during the Platts “window” for the express purpose of pushing down the price assessment and hence the price of the fuel oil that Glencore purchased. The bids and offers were not submitted to Platts for any legitimate economic reason by company employees, but rather for the purpose of artificially affecting the relevant Platts price assessment so that the benchmark price, and hence the price of fuel oil that the company bought from, and sold to, another party, did not reflect legitimate forces of supply and demand.
Between approximately September 2012 and August 2016, Glencore Ltd employees conspired to manipulate the price of fuel oil bought from, and sold to, a corrupt counterparty (Company A) through private, bilateral contracts, by manipulating the Platts price assessment for Los Angeles Fuel. Between approximately January 2014 and February 2016, Glencore engaged in a “joint venture” with Company A, which involved buying fuel oil from Company A at prices artificially depressed by Glencore’s manipulation of the Platts Los Angeles Fuel benchmark. Finally, between approximately January 2011 and August 2019, company employees conspired to manipulate the price of fuel oil bought and sold through private, bilateral contracts, as well as derivative positions, by manipulating the Platts price assessment for US Gulf Coast Fuel Oil.
The CFTC also noted Glencore was involved in market manipulation through illegally obtaining confidential information by improperly obtained nonpublic information from employees and agents of the state-owned enterprises (SOEs), including Pemex in Mexico. This information was material to Glencore’s business and trading. Pemex agents who had access to confidential information and owed a duty to Pemex under Mexican law and Pemex internal policies to keep the information confidential—disclosed nonpublic information, “including information material to Glencore’s transactions with the SOE or to related physical and derivatives trading, to Glencore. Glencore traders in knowing possession of the confidential information then entered into related physical transactions and derivatives transactions.”
Finally, as we noted in yesterday’s recitation of the FCPA allegations, Glencore made corrupt payments to employees and agents working at SOEs in Brazil, Cameroon, Nigeria, and Venezuela. Glencore or its affiliates made the corrupt payments in exchange for improper preferential treatment and access to trades with the SOEs. Glencore’s conduct was designed to increase Glencore’s profits from certain physical and derivatives trading in oil markets around the world, including US physical and derivatives markets. Glencore also engaged in this corrupt conduct in connection with derivatives such as swaps and futures contracts subject to the rules of Commission-registered entities.
Tomorrow we will consider the settlement.