Categories
Blog

Cross-Atlantic Fraud & Corruption Enforcement: Intersections and Divergences

In today’s dynamic compliance landscape, navigating the complexities of international corporate wrongdoing requires vigilance, foresight, and strategic action, as highlighted in A recent article entitled “Cross-Atlantic Impact: DOJ and SFO Self-Reporting and Enforcement Priorities,” by lawyers from McDermott, Will & Schulte. The article is an excellent review of areas where the fight against fraud and corruption aligns between the two countries and areas where they diverge. Today, I will review the article and consider what it means for the US company doing business in the UK or with UK companies.

The Serious Fraud Office (SFO) in the United Kingdom has made clear its expectations regarding self-reporting corporate misconduct, mainly aligning in philosophy, if not always in exact details, with its U.S. counterpart, the Department of Justice (DOJ). American companies must understand these nuances and adapt their compliance programs accordingly. Here are five critical reasons why U.S. businesses must closely monitor and adhere to the UK’s evolving fraud and bribery enforcement regime.

Prompt Self-Reporting Weighs Heavily in Favor of DPAs

The SFO guidance unequivocally states that companies demonstrating prompt self-reporting of corporate wrongdoing significantly increase their chances of obtaining a Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA). Conversely, any delay in self-reporting suspected wrongdoing “within a reasonable time of it coming to light” adversely impacts the company’s standing with the SFO.

Much like the DOJ, the SFO does not insist on complete internal investigations before self-reporting. Indeed, in many ways, both sets of prosecutors want companies to step forward as soon as possible. The degree of the inquiry expected depends on the clarity and strength of evidence. Where evidence indicates wrongdoing, companies are expected to self-report swiftly. Ambiguities may permit a more extensive preliminary investigation, but American companies should note that delays can risk losing the advantages offered by early disclosure.

Jurisdictional Triggers Demand Simultaneous Reporting

For American companies dealing with potential misconduct spanning jurisdictions, awareness and agility become paramount. According to SFO guidance, companies reporting suspected misconduct to another agency, such as the DOJ, should also inform the SFO simultaneously or immediately thereafter. Failure to do so negates any potential credit for self-reporting.

Consider a scenario where a company seeks a declination from the DOJ through prompt self-disclosure. Identifying a UK jurisdictional nexus, such as conduct occurring partly in the UK or financial impact felt within the UK, is crucial. The UK’s “failure to prevent bribery” and new “failure to prevent fraud” offenses can impose liability based on international conduct linked to a business presence or financial repercussions in the UK. Understanding and navigating these jurisdictional nuances quickly is imperative to safeguard against regulatory pitfalls and secure favorable treatment.

Increasingly Aggressive Fraud Enforcement

Fraud has emerged as a prominent enforcement priority for both the DOJ and SFO. American companies should pay particular attention to the UK’s new “failure to prevent fraud” (FTPF) offense, effective from September 1, 2025. This robust enforcement tool targets UK and non-UK entities whose associates engage in fraudulent conduct impacting UK interests.

American companies operating internationally must proactively establish “reasonable fraud prevention procedures” to counteract potential liability under this legislation. The urgency conveyed by the SFO, highlighted by senior officials expressing eagerness to utilize these new powers aggressively, cannot be overstated. Companies that neglect preparation risk being among the first prosecuted examples of this powerful legislation.

Coordination Between DOJ and SFO Enhances Risk Exposure

With the DOJ emphasizing fraud in areas affecting U.S. interests, ranging from healthcare and procurement fraud to investment scams, there is considerable overlap with misconduct addressed by the UK’s FTP fraud offense. The authors note that the US Supreme Court held in Kousisis v. United States that a defendant may be convicted of wire fraud for inducing a victim to enter a contract under material pretenses, even if there was no economic loss to the victim. This ruling may allow US prosecutors to pursue a broader range of fraud cases.”

A cross-jurisdictional approach is therefore essential. American companies uncovering fraud that victimizes both U.S. and UK entities or markets must carefully assess reporting obligations to both jurisdictions. The simultaneous or nearly simultaneous reporting requirements heighten the stakes and complexity, demanding robust internal mechanisms for rapid assessment and disclosure.

Continuing Vigorous Anti-Bribery Efforts Globally

Despite temporary uncertainties in the DOJ’s stance toward anti-bribery enforcement, global initiatives indicate relentless international focus. The SFO has intensified anti-bribery efforts through initiatives like the International Anti-Corruption Prosecutorial Taskforce, collaborating closely with French and Swiss authorities. The SFO’s involvement in the International Anti-Corruption Coordination Centre (IACCC) further underscores its commitment. The authors report that “the IACCC aims to facilitate international cooperation on ‘grand corruption’ investigations, including concerning intelligence and evidence gathering.”

In addition to the IACCC, “In March 2025, the SFO established an ‘International Anti-Corruption Prosecutorial Taskforce’ with the French Parquet National Financier (PNF) and the Office of the Attorney General of Switzerland (OAG) (Taskforce). Through the Taskforce, the SFO, PNF, and OAG commit to strengthening their existing cooperation and collaborating to deploy their wide-reaching anti-bribery legislation to prosecute overseas conduct.”

The DOJ’s recent reaffirmation of anti-bribery efforts through its White-Collar Enforcement Plan, highlighting bribery and money laundering harming U.S. interests, may complement these international initiatives. American companies must remain vigilant regarding potential liabilities under both the FCPA and the UK Bribery Act, carefully calibrating their compliance programs to meet rigorous enforcement expectations across jurisdictions.

Practical Steps for American Companies

Given these compelling reasons to pay close attention to the SFO guidance and evolving UK legislation, American companies must take proactive steps to fortify their compliance efforts:

  • Enhance Internal Controls: Companies must quickly develop comprehensive “reasonable fraud prevention procedures,” supported by thorough risk assessments and regularly updated policies.
  • Cross-Jurisdictional Risk Assessments: Implement rigorous processes for promptly assessing jurisdictional ties when misconduct emerges, allowing immediate and coordinated reporting where necessary.
  • Integrated Compliance Training: Ensure global compliance teams, legal counsel, and executive management understand SFO and DOJ expectations clearly, fostering prompt, informed responses.
  • Monitoring International Developments: Maintain continuous awareness of evolving enforcement policies and initiatives, particularly regarding fraud and bribery, to swiftly adapt compliance programs accordingly.
  • Preparedness and Responsiveness: Establish clear protocols for internal investigations and self-reporting decisions, emphasizing speed and comprehensiveness to maximize potential cooperation credit.

Conclusion

Navigating the intricate and often intersecting expectations of the SFO and DOJ presents ongoing challenges for American companies. However, understanding the strategic implications of prompt self-reporting, jurisdictional coordination, aggressive fraud enforcement, international collaboration, and robust anti-bribery efforts is vital.

Proactive compliance management, aligned closely with evolving international regulatory landscapes, is not merely advisable but something that every multinational needs to put in place. American corporations should approach compliance with the understanding that today’s oversight environment demands swift and strategic decision-making to mitigate risks effectively and position themselves favorably in the face of potential regulatory scrutiny.

Categories
FCPA Compliance Report

FCPA Compliance Report – 10 Core Principles for Effective Internal Investigations with Michelle Peirce

Welcome to the award-winning FCPA Compliance Report, the longest-running podcast in compliance. In this episode, Tom Fox welcomes Michelle Peirce from Hinckley Allen, where she co-chairs the White Collar and Government Enforcement Group.

They take a deep dive into Michelle’s article on the 10 Core Principles Common to Internal Investigations, discussing topics such as the importance of understanding the investigation’s purpose, maintaining privilege, the role of an engagement letter, deciding between written reports and verbal summaries, and the significance of billing and internal communications. Michelle also shares her insights from her professional background, including her experience as a special assistant district attorney, and touches on current pressures on compliance tied to self-disclosure to the DOJ. The conversation offers a comprehensive guide for organizations on conducting successful internal investigations.

Key highlights:

  • Role and Challenges in Internal Investigations
  • Core Principles of Internal Investigations
  • Importance of Privilege and Engagement Letters
  • Written vs. Verbal Reports
  • Order and Structure of Investigations
  • Professionalism and Billing in Investigations

Resources:

Michelle Peirce on LinkedIn

Michelle Peirce at Hinckley Allen

10 Core Principles Common to Internal Investigations

Tom Fox

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

LinkedIn

For more information on the use of AI in compliance programs, my new book is Upping Your Game. You can purchase a copy of the book on Amazon.com.

Categories
2 Gurus Talk Compliance

2 Gurus Talk Compliance – Episode 55 – The From Worse to Worser Edition

What happens when two top compliance commentators get together? They talk compliance, of course. Join Tom Fox and Kristy Grant-Hart in 2 Gurus Talk Compliance as they discuss the latest compliance issues in this week’s episode!

Stories this week include:

  • What happens when your bot goes antisemitic? (NYT)
  • BRG modeled a plan to settle Palestinians. (FT)
  • Goldman to demand loyalty oaths. (Bloomberg)
  • NFLPA head works for private equity. (ESPN)
  • Bid-rigging in stadium development. (WSJ)
  • Airbus, ASML, Mistral Bosses Ask EU to Pause AI Rules. (WSJ)
  • EU Omnibus Simplification Package Update. (Gibson Dunn)
  • Antitrust Whistleblower Program Launched. (Radical Compliance)
  • Unfinished Business at the Department of Justice. (Ideas & Answers)
  • ‘Today is his birthday’: Man allegedly stole a tour train high on meth, picked up passengers. (Florida Local 12)

Resources:

Kristy Grant-Hart on LinkedIn

Prove Your Worth

Tom

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

LinkedIn

Categories
Daily Compliance News

Daily Compliance News: July 17, 2025, The COSO Yanked Edition

Welcome to the Daily Compliance News. Each day, Tom Fox, the Voice of Compliance, brings you compliance-related stories to start your day. Sit back, enjoy a cup of morning coffee, and listen in to the Daily Compliance News. All, from the Compliance Podcast Network. Each day, we consider four stories from the business world, including compliance, ethics, risk management, leadership, or general interest, relevant to the compliance professional.

Top compliance stories:

  • DOJ fires Maxwell prosecutor. (WSJ)
  • ABC heads to the BVI to find out why it is dragging its feet. (The Guardian)
  • COSO pulls its Corporate Governance Framework (Radical Compliance)
  • Samsung boss cleared of fraud charges. (BBC)

You can donate to flood relief for victims of the Kerr County flooding by going to the Hill Country Flood Relief here.

Categories
Blog

Rewarding Integrity: Five Lessons from the DOJ – USPS Whistleblower MOU

⁠As compliance professionals, we stand at the forefront of integrity, transparency, and accountability within our organizations. Recently, an important document has emerged from the Antitrust Division of the United States Department of Justice (Antitrust Division), the United States Postal Service (USPS), and the United States Postal Service Office of Inspector General (USPS OIG)—the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) regarding the Whistleblower Rewards Program. This MOU represents a significant advancement in promoting corporate transparency, encouraging ethical behavior, and strengthening the reporting channels for criminal antitrust violations.

Understanding the MOU

The MOU is a collaborative agreement among the Antitrust Division of the DOJ, the USPS, and the USPS OIG, designed to establish and operationalize a Whistleblower Rewards Program. The overarching purpose is to incentivize whistleblowers to step forward and report credible and substantial evidence of criminal violations, especially those related to antitrust activities that directly impact the Postal Service’s operations or revenues.

Specifically, this program addresses serious federal criminal offenses, including price fixing, bid rigging, market allocation, and other forms of economic collusion, as well as associated fraud schemes that undermine the integrity of government procurement processes. The initiative reflects a comprehensive and coordinated effort among the Antitrust Division, the USPS, and the USPS OIG to foster accountability and transparency in federal contracts, procurements, and market practices.

A critical component of this MOU is the articulated process for whistleblower engagement and eligibility for rewards. Whistleblowers are encouraged to voluntarily submit original information, which must be specific, credible, timely, and previously unknown to any of the enforcement authorities. Once submitted, this information undergoes a rigorous review by the Antitrust Division, which evaluates its validity, specificity, and potential impact. If the initial assessment finds merit, the information is forwarded to the USPS Inspection Service (USPIS), which determines its relevance to the Postal Service’s operations or finances.

A distinctive feature of the Whistleblower Rewards Program, as detailed in the MOU, is the financial incentive offered to successful whistleblowers. Individuals whose reports lead directly to a criminal prosecution, conviction, deferred prosecution agreement, or non-prosecution agreement resulting in a monetary fine or recovery of at least $1 million may receive financial rewards ranging from 15% to 30% of the collected fine. This explicit reward structure serves to underscore the commitment of federal authorities to rewarding transparency, integrity, and courageous reporting of wrongdoing, providing a clear incentive for ethical action within organizations.

By outlining clear processes, defined roles, specific reporting criteria, and attractive financial incentives, this MOU establishes a strong blueprint for enhancing corporate and governmental compliance efforts, underscoring the critical role whistleblowers play in upholding economic integrity and ethical business conduct.

Five Key Takeaways for the Compliance Professional

1. Embrace Proactive Whistleblower Policies

A primary lesson from this MOU is the importance of proactively establishing robust whistleblower frameworks within your organization. This program demonstrates how structured whistleblower initiatives, backed by clear protocols and monetary incentives, significantly bolster compliance efforts. Organizations should similarly adopt proactive approaches, ensuring their whistleblower programs are transparent, well-publicized, and accessible to all employees and stakeholders. Always remember that 80% of all reported whistleblowers either attempt or do report internally. It is the remaining 20% who go to the government.

2. Original Information and Clear Reporting Channels

Compliance programs must ensure clarity around what constitutes “original information,” as defined by this MOU. Information must be independently obtained, credible, specific, and previously unknown to the enforcement authorities. Clear communication channels and robust internal reporting mechanisms are essential for employees to feel confident in sharing valuable insights, thus fostering an internal culture of integrity and vigilance.

3. Integration with Law Enforcement

Another critical takeaway is the integration and alignment of organizational compliance with external law enforcement agencies. By closely coordinating with entities such as the DOJ Antitrust Division, organizations not only enhance their compliance measures but also demonstrate their commitment to lawful operations and proactive detection of violations. Regular dialogue and clear lines of communication with regulatory and enforcement authorities can ensure alignment and swift action on identified risks.

4. Transparency in Award Determination

The MOU emphasizes transparency and fairness in the distribution of rewards. Rewards are stipulated to range from 15% to 30% of the collected criminal fines, promoting trust and clarity among potential whistleblowers. Compliance professionals must adopt a similarly transparent approach within internal reward and recognition structures, clearly communicating criteria, processes, and the rationale behind award decisions. Transparency fosters trust, boosts morale, and encourages active participation in compliance initiatives.

5. Limitations and Conditions for Whistleblowers

Understanding the MOU’s explicit exclusions and conditions is essential. Individuals excluded from whistleblower eligibility include those who instigated the violation, those with privileged or confidential compliance responsibilities, and those employed by law enforcement or regulatory bodies. Compliance professionals must delineate roles and responsibilities within their organizations, ensuring all team members understand their obligations, the nature of confidential and privileged information, and the boundaries of reporting mechanisms.

Final Thoughts

This Whistleblower Rewards Program MOU is a robust model for fostering a compliance culture and encouraging ethical conduct within corporations. By providing clear incentives, establishing transparent processes, and maintaining close collaboration with regulatory bodies, this program sets a high standard for organizations across industries.

As compliance leaders, it is our responsibility to champion these principles within our organizations, advocating for stronger whistleblower protections, clearer reporting channels, and greater collaboration with external oversight authorities. Only by doing so can we build resilient, transparent, and ethically robust organizations prepared to face tomorrow’s compliance challenges head-on.

Categories
FCPA Compliance Report

FCPA Compliance Report – Stay the Course: Ellen Lafferty on Navigating Anti-Corruption Compliance in 2025

Welcome to the award-winning FCPA Compliance Report, the longest-running podcast in compliance. Today, Tom Fox welcomes Ellen Lafferty, a well-known figure in the compliance community with a distinguished career in both financial and educational institutions.

Ellen discusses her new book, ‘Anti-Bribery and Corruption Law and Compliance In a Nutshell,’ detailing what inspired her to write it and how it can serve as a comprehensive reference for both legal and compliance professionals. They explore Ellen’s transition from litigator to in-house compliance officer, emphasizing the importance of understanding the ultimate audience in legal advice. They also discuss the implications of recent changes in FCPA enforcement priorities by the U.S. government as of 2025 and how compliance professionals should adapt. Ellen emphasizes the importance of maintaining rigorous compliance programs and provides practical guidance on conducting self-assessments and gap analyses to ensure robust anti-bribery and corruption measures.

Key highlights:

  • Ellen Lafferty’s Career and Book Inspiration
  • Transition from Litigator to Compliance Officer
  • Scope and Audience of the Book
  • Current Compliance Landscape in 2025
  • Advice for Compliance Professionals

Resources:

Ellen Lafferty on LinkedIn

West Academic Publishing

Anti-Bribery and Corruption Law and Compliance in a Nutshell on Amazon

Tom Fox

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

LinkedIn

For more information on the use of AI in Compliance programs, my new book, Upping Your Game. You can purchase a copy of the book on Amazon.com.

Categories
10 For 10

10 For 10: Top Compliance Stories For the Week Ending, June 28, 2025

Welcome to 10 For 10, the podcast that brings you the week’s Top 10 compliance stories in one podcast each week. Tom Fox, the Voice of Compliance, brings you the compliance professionals and compliance stories you need to be aware of to end your busy week. Sit back, and in 10 minutes, hear about the stories every compliance professional should be aware of from the prior week. Every Saturday, 10 For 10 highlights the most important news, insights, and analysis for the compliance professional, all curated by Tom Fox, the Voice of Compliance. Get your weekly filling of compliance stories with 10 for 10, a podcast produced by the Compliance Podcast Network.

  • Is it a lawsuit settlement or a bribe? (WSJ)
  • Staley ban upheld by British court. (FT)
  • ABB was released from its DPA early. (Lexology)
  • Matt Galvin was honored as FT Top 20 Innovative Lawyer. (FT)
  • OpenAI can train on copyrighted material. (BBC)
  • PCAOB elimination hits a roadblock. (WSJ)
  • Tesla was threatened in France for deceptive marketing. (FT)
  • Is it safe for Americans to travel abroad? (NYT)
  • Is bias built into hiring algorithms? (WSJ)
  • Are Canadian companies at risk due to the US’s lack of ABC enforcement? (Globe and Mail)

You can check out the Daily Compliance News for four curated compliance and ethics-related stories each day here.

Connect with Tom 

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

LinkedIn

You can purchase a copy of my new book, Upping Your Game, on Amazon.com

Categories
Daily Compliance News

Daily Compliance News: June 27, 2025, The ABB Gets Out of DPA Edition

Welcome to the Daily Compliance News. Each day, Tom Fox, the Voice of Compliance, brings you compliance-related stories to start your day. Sit back, enjoy a cup of morning coffee, and listen in to the Daily Compliance News. All from the Compliance Podcast Network. Each day, we consider four stories from the business world: compliance, ethics, risk management, leadership, and general interest, all of which are relevant to the compliance professional.

Top compliance stories:

  • Is it a lawsuit settlement or a bribe? (WSJ)
  • Staley ban upheld by British court. (FT)
  • Data and shareholder capitalism. (Bloomberg)
  • ABB was released from its DPA early. (Lexology)
Categories
Blog

The Boeing 737 Max Imbroglio: Part 2 – A Path Forward with a Special Master

In recent weeks, the spotlight has again intensified on The Boeing Company, following a provocative motion filed by families of victims from the tragic 737 Max crashes. They have petitioned a Texas federal judge to appoint a special prosecutor in Boeing’s criminal conspiracy case, arguing fervently against the Department of Justice’s recent Non-Prosecution Agreement (NPA) with Boeing. At stake is not merely corporate accountability but, fundamentally, the integrity of our justice system itself. If all a company is required to do under the Department of Justice (DOJ) is throw money at a series of problems, there will never be true reform.

Yesterday, I began a two-part look at the current set of issues raised in the DOJ capitulation to Boeing, its ignoring of the families of the crash victims, and its complete lack of holding Boeing accountable beyond financial penalties. Today, I want to conclude this short series by proposing a path forward that helps to ameliorate the rights of the parties as well as all the other stakeholders involved in this Boeing imbroglio.

For reasons that are not articulated, the DOJ has dropped its requirement for an Independent Corporate Monitor to oversee the overhaul of culture at Boeing, instead allowing a Boeing-hired compliance consultant to be part of the process. This is wholly insufficient as it requires zero transparency for any of the key parties to the litigation: the families of the victims of the 737 MAX crashes, the Court, and even the DOJ itself. Indeed, the DOJ did not even consult with the families of the victims, as it was reported that the DOJ gave them one day’s notice that it was going to provide Boeing with a Non-Prosecution Agreement (NPA) with no Independent Compliance Monitor.

The significance of an Independent Compliance Monitor tasked with overseeing Boeing’s adherence to compliance and safety protocols over the next three years cannot be overstated. The role of an Independent Compliance Monitor in this case should be expansive. Beyond traditional compliance responsibilities, such as policies, procedures, internal controls, and training, the Independent Compliance Monitor should also address anti-fraud measures, safety, and quality assurance/control (QA/QC) issues. This broader remit is essential, given the systemic failures at Boeing that contributed to the 737 MAX disasters. (Looming, of course, is the 787 Dreamliner crash in India.)

The DOJ previously found disturbing lapses in Boeing’s safety and quality records.  It is unclear whether the DOJ has revised these findings in light of its proposed NPA. Boeing employees reported feeling pressured to prioritize productivity and financial performance over safety and quality, a cultural flaw that contributed to the compliance breaches. This pressure led to out-of-sequence work, poor record-keeping, and inadequate safety audits, all of which are indicative of a deeper systemic problem.

Addressing these issues requires a comprehensive culture-focused approach. An Independent Compliance Monitor must not only enforce existing standards but also foster a culture of integrity and transparency within Boeing. This involves ensuring that employees can report concerns without fear of retaliation and that safety protocols are rigorously followed and documented.

The families of the crash victims are not mere bystanders in this process. They have voiced strong objections to this NPA, particularly its leniency and the lack of accountability for senior executives, as well as for any future actions by Boeing. They argue that the NPA exonerates those responsible for the safety lapses. This concern resonates with many compliance professionals who advocate for robust accountability at all levels of an organization.

In light of the unique facts and procedural history of this matter, judicial oversight will be crucial in ensuring that an Independent Compliance Monitor leads to genuine remediation. Transparency is a cornerstone of effective compliance and accountability, and its absence could undermine the entire process.

This is where the District Court should step in and appoint a Special Master to act as an Independent Compliance Monitor. Under the Federal Rules of Procedure, a District Court can appoint a Special Master to monitor compliance with court orders or settlement agreements. This can be especially useful in cases where the parties have a history of noncompliance or need ongoing oversight. The appointment of a Special Master is a powerful option for this specific fact pattern.

For Boeing to restore its reputation and regain public trust, it must go beyond the minimum requirements of the NPA. This involves a commitment to comprehensive remediation, encompassing cultural change, structural reforms, and rigorous enforcement of safety and compliance standards. All done with transparency.

A Special Master’s remit would be a step in the right direction, but it must be accompanied by genuine transparency and accountability. This includes involving the victims’ families in meaningful ways, such as through regular updates and consultations, and ensuring that their concerns are addressed substantively. In other words, transparency.

The Boeing case serves as a stark reminder of the critical importance of compliance, transparency, and accountability in the corporate world. It highlights the devastating consequences of systemic failures and the urgent need for robust oversight mechanisms. As compliance professionals, we must advocate for comprehensive and transparent processes that ensure not only compliance with legal standards but also the fostering of a culture of integrity and responsibility.

Ultimately, true remediation and accountability are in the best interests of all stakeholders, from the victims’ families seeking justice to the company itself, which strives to rebuild its reputation and restore public trust.  The DOJ has completely abrogated its role in this moving forward. However, the District Court can facilitate this process by appointing a Special Master who can act as an Independent Compliance Monitor.

The path forward is clear: there must be a firm commitment to rigorous compliance, transparent practices, and a culture that prioritizes safety and integrity above all else. However, this must be accompanied by independent oversight. If the DOJ does not wish to assume this role, the District Court should consider appointing a Special Master. Only then can it hope to move beyond the shadows of the 737 MAX scandal and emerge as a leader in the aviation industry once again.

Categories
Blog

The Boeing 737 Max Imbroglio: Part 1 – The DOJ Ditches Transparency

In recent weeks, the spotlight has again intensified on The Boeing Company, following a provocative motion filed by families of victims from the tragic 737 Max crashes. They have petitioned a Texas federal judge to appoint a special prosecutor in Boeing’s criminal conspiracy case, arguing fervently against the Department of Justice’s recent Non-Prosecution Agreement (NPA) with Boeing. At stake is not merely corporate accountability but, fundamentally, the integrity of our justice system itself. Today, I begin a two-part look at the current set of issues raised in the DOJ capitulation to Boeing, its ignoring of the families of the crash victims, and its complete lack of holding Boeing accountable beyond financial penalties.

The victims’ families and the general flying public represent crucial stakeholders who deserve answers, accountability, and assurances of safety. Disturbingly, the DOJ’s actions appear dismissive of these stakeholders. This lack of consideration significantly undermines public confidence in Boeing and the effectiveness of regulatory enforcement.

The victims’ families seek accountability, including criminal charges for executives, strict compliance oversight, and transparency to prevent future disasters.  Instead, they have received a diminished settlement and an opaque independent consultant, leaving them rightly skeptical and outraged, all of which occurred without any meaningful consultation with the DOJ. At its core, the families argue, the DOJ’s latest move sets a hazardous precedent, allowing corporations essentially to circumvent accountability through financial settlements and carefully crafted agreements.

The current controversy revolves around the DOJ’s decision to dismiss a conspiracy charge under the conditions outlined in the $1.1 billion NPA. This agreement, critics assert, permits Boeing to effectively “buy its way out of a criminal conviction,” marking a disturbing shift in how corporate criminal cases might be handled going forward.

The families’ legal representatives have raised compelling arguments about why the NPA represents a perilous deviation from standard judicial procedures. Specifically, their motion asserts that the NPA dangerously erodes the separation of powers by attempting to bypass the judicial review requirement mandated by the Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 48(a). Such maneuvering, the families contend, could become a worrying precedent that effectively creates a new branch of governmental power, immune to the checks and balances essential to American governance.

Moreover, this case highlights critical issues surrounding the Crime Victims’ Rights Act (CVRA), legislation designed to ensure victims and their families are treated fairly throughout judicial proceedings. The families argue passionately that the NPA, in its current form, diminishes their statutory rights and sidesteps meaningful accountability, thus undermining the broader principles of justice.

Equally concerning is Boeing’s historical engagement with DOJ agreements. Initially, under a Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA) brokered in 2021, Boeing pledged reforms and accepted specific responsibilities. However, a disturbing mid-air incident involving a Boeing 737 Max 9 jet in January 2024 revealed serious safety oversights and compliance deficiencies, prompting the DOJ to reexamine Boeing’s commitments. Boeing’s readiness to plead guilty evaporated swiftly when the political landscape appeared favorable, a clear indication, families argue, that the aerospace giant’s commitments were strategic rather than genuine.

This raises fundamental questions about corporate culture, accountability, and oversight. Compliance professionals everywhere must consider: What mechanisms truly ensure meaningful corporate reform? Can performative contrition substitute for authentic, monitored change?

Under the revised NPA, Boeing has agreed to pay significant fines and allocate funds to victim compensation and program enhancements for compliance. Yet notably absent from this agreement is any oversight mechanism akin to the independent compliance monitor stipulated in previous arrangements. Instead, Boeing must merely retain an independent compliance consultant, a far softer requirement and one that has rightly alarmed observers concerned with genuine reform.

From a compliance standpoint, the removal of the independent monitor provision is a clear red flag. Monitors are essential to verifying that changes implemented within a corporation are genuine, sustained, and effective. By settling for a consultant rather than an empowered, independent monitor, the DOJ is creating an environment that is ripe for surface-level reforms that fail to address deeply rooted, systemic issues.

This scenario underscores a crucial lesson for corporate compliance professionals: genuine compliance reforms cannot rely solely on internal assurances or perfunctory oversight. Rigorous external verification mechanisms are essential to ensuring that compliance efforts are meaningful, impactful, and sustained over the long term. The bottom line is that transparency is the key, and this DOJ has completely deleted any Boeing requirement for transparency in its remediation process.

Furthermore, this case illustrates the importance of judicial independence and the robust application of oversight principles. Without vigilant oversight, corporations could increasingly perceive settlements as mere financial calculations rather than genuine opportunities to recalibrate organizational ethics and compliance cultures. Compliance professionals must advocate for and implement frameworks that prioritize meaningful oversight and genuine reform.

As compliance leaders, we must recognize the far-reaching implications of the Boeing case. This case serves as a stark reminder that true corporate reform cannot be bought—it must be earned through demonstrable, monitored change. Regulators and justice departments globally must hold corporations accountable not just financially but also operationally and culturally.

The demand by the victims’ families for a special prosecutor highlights a crucial juncture. Will we endorse a system where accountability is negotiable and oversight diluted? Or will we reaffirm the essential tenets of justice, ensuring robust judicial review, stringent oversight of compliance, and genuine corporate reform?

Boeing’s future actions, closely scrutinized, will reflect its genuine commitment to change. Compliance professionals, corporate leaders, and regulators alike must take heed—reform without rigorous oversight is merely an empty promise. The integrity of corporate compliance demands far more.

Ultimately, the Boeing case offers a powerful lesson: the pursuit of meaningful corporate compliance and ethical integrity requires more than financial penalties; it demands transparency, accountability, and true oversight. For corporations, anything less risks not only reputational harm but also the profound erosion of public trust, which is essential to long-term sustainability.

Tomorrow, we will explore a court-imposed solution to this imbroglio.